Saturday, November 10, 2007

The difference between bodies and machines

There's something that's been bugging me lately in a lot of the reading I've been doing. It started bugging me a while ago - probably even a year ago - but I didn't really think it important then. But this week during my reading I came across the Psymbiote project.

isa gordon, whose body provides the scaffolding for symbiote, is a very young and attractive woman (though it might be more accurate to say her body is being incorporated into Psymbiote, at least according her conceptualization of the project). Which got me thinking.

See, I used to have one of those young, tight, and attractive bodies like hers. Used to. The older I get, the looser things get in general, and of course the older I get, the less my body can be described as young. This is not unusual. It happens to everyone. (Or at least everyone who doesn't go under a plastic surgeon's knife... and even then, there's no way to really turn back the clock.) I'm not saying this out of bitterness, please don't get me wrong there. I'm rather happy with the state of my body... and my mind and my soul come to think of it. I'm really rather satisfied with the state of things. But this satisfaction has only come as a recognition of the inevitability of that loosening that takes place as our bodies age.

But I'm starting to digress from the point.

My point is that the human body changes throughout it's lifecycle. When you think of what a newborn human looks like, their proportions are different than an adult. Any adult that had the head-body proportion of an infant would look freakish. And of course children have to learn how to control the voluntary functions of their bodies.

ASIDE: There's a whole other argument out there regarding human bodies and tools, that envisions the human body as a tool which we gradually learn to use, but that's another issue and would have to be a different post. It also is an issue that I discuss in the dissertation, but so far my thinking about it isn't complete, so if a post is ever forthcoming, it will have to wait.
But the point is that human bodies change. We all know this. Yet whenever I read, or hear discussions about how our bodies and our machines will become more closely integrated with each other, the technophiles who write these things usually ignore that changing body.

They act as if the body they inhabit is the body they always have and always will inhabit.

Now as I said, I didn't really think about it much. I was aware these theorists were ignoring the changes in the body, but didn't really think about why myself. I pretty much chalked it up to the fact that the theorists who I've encountered talking about this are men.

Now, before the word "sexism" can pop into your head, let me try to explain. I will grant that it is sexist of me to expect that men writing about bodies and technology will ignore the body to a greater extent than women might. Yes, I'm guilty of thinking that. BUT. It wasn't so much that these were men writing, but that they were adopting a maculinist point of view.

Several months ago I read N. Katherine Hayles How We Became Posthuman. In it, she talks about the history of cybernetics - I would highly recommend the book if you're looking for a general discussion of cybernetics that incorporates its history with analysis of its emergence in literature e.g. Gibson, Stephenson etc. She recognizes that much cybernetic discussion dismisses the body, and when it does discuss the body, it is a normalized body, which is imagined to be white, adult and male.

If you think about it, she's right. Most of the time, the cyborg is this. Look at Robocop. Look at Terminator. Look at Case, the console cowboy. Look at Hiro Protagonist. Look at Johnny Mnemonic. All men. All white. All adult. Which means that they inhabit bodies that can go for years and years without changing.

For women, change occurs much more easily. For adult women of the same age as these men, there's the possibility that their body will change every month for a few days. There's also the very real possibility that their body will change shape radically if, for example, they become pregnant. And of course the nursing afterwards changes the shape of the body just as its function changes.

Which is why I started tweaking about this idea when I saw Psymbiote. In one of the pictures on her webpage, it shows how she was fitted for a kind of exoskeleton that she'll wear. It looks to be made of fiberglass. Now, fiberglass, when it's unprocessed, is highly malleable. But once you've formed it, it's very solid. (I dated a guy who worked in a fiberglass factory for a while, so I probably know more about it than is really necessary for an adult to know.)

My first thought on seeing this photo?

"What happens if her arm changes shape?"

Well, what does happen?

If Psymbiote is the combination of isa and technology, then what happens when isa changes so that the technology no longer fits comfortably into/onto her body? It will happen. isa's body will change. It may not change for many years. It may not change by much. But it will change.

If the technology attached to her body is indeed symbiotic, as is the project's supposed aim, then what happens when one member of that symbiotic relationship changes? How extensive are the effects?

In nature, if one organism in a symbiotic relationship changes, it can affect the health and even life of the other. Would a symbiotic relationship with a machine be the same? If you think about what would happen if the machine changes, imagines of all those disastrous science fiction scenarios where people are damaged by damaged machines certainly come to mind. Would the reverse be the same? Would a change in the human damage the machine?

And of course, this leads to the question of how much we can really integrate the body with machines, since in order for machines to change, they require an outside agent to effect that change (at least our machines of today - perhaps we'll invent machines that can alter their own structure in the future, the same as how we alter our body structures, intentionally or not). Our bodies can change through outside agency. But they also frequently change without any external intervention.

Of course what got me thinking about this is that Psymbiote's organic component - isa gordon - is clearly female. What if not just her arm changes, but large parts of her body if she chose to be pregnant? How would that affect those static technological pieces? How would it potentially constrain the function of her pregnant body? Can technology/machine adapt to interact in such an intimate manner as Psymbiote is constructed to act if the organic components of it change?

No matter how imaginative I get about it, I keep coming to the same conclusion. The machines that exist today, that are not able to adapt their form to changing circumstances, would be ill equipped to interact intimately with a human body that is capable of changing - often in radical ways - in response to its function a.k.a. its changing physiology.

This is a fundamental difference between humans and machines: our ever changing and changeable bodies. Until machines are capable of such change, there will always exist a gap between us and them that will make intimate mergings of body and machine difficult to say the least.

Friday, November 09, 2007

Flip side

"In the game of life and evolution there are three players at the table: human beings, nature, and machines. I am firmly on the side of nature. But nature, I suspect, is on the side of the machines".
George B Dyson Darwin Among the Machines

Wednesday, November 07, 2007

How to deke out an American*

As a Canadian, you have to be extra vigilant. There are a lot of impostors out there. If you suspect that someone is falsely trying to pass themselves off as a Canadian, make the following statement - and then carefully note their reaction:

"Last night, I cashed my pogey and went to buy a mickey of C.C. at the offsale, but my skidoo got stuck in the muskeg on my way back to the duplex.I was trying to deke out a deer, you see. Damn chinook, melted everything. And then a Mountie snuck up behind me in a ghost car and gave me an impaired. I was S.O.L., sitting there dressed only in my Stanfields and a toque at the time. And the Mountie, he's all chippy and everything, calling me a "shit disturber" and what not. What could I say, except, "Sorry, EH!"

If the person you are talking to nods sympathetically, they're one of us. If, however, they stare at you with a blank incomprehension, they are not a real Canadian. Have them reported to the authorities at once.

The passage cited above contains no fewer than 19 different Canadianisms.
In order:

pogey: EI (Employment insurance). Money provided by the government for not working.
mickey: A small bottle of booze (13 oz) (A Texas mickey, on the other hand, is a ridiculously big bottle of booze, which, despite the name, is still a Canadianism through and through.)
C.C.: Canadian Club, a brand of rye. Not to be confused with "hockey stick," another kind of Canadian Club.
offsale: Beer store.
skidoo: Self-propelled decapitation unit for teenagers.
muskeg: Boggy swampland.
duplex: A single building divided in half with two sets of inhabitants, each trying to pretend the other doesn't exist while at the same time managing to drive each other crazy; metaphor for Canada's french and english.
deke: Used as a verb, it means "to fool an opponent through skillful misdirection." As a noun, it is used most often in exclamatory constructions, such as: "Whadda deke!" Meaning, "My, what an impressive display of physical dexterity employing misdirection and guile."
chinook:An unseasonably warm wind that comes over the Rockies and onto the plains, melting snow banks in Calgary but just missing Edmonton, much to the pleasure of Calgarians.
Mountie:Canadian icon, strong of jaw, red of coat, pure of heart. Always get their man! (See also Pepper spray, uses of.)
snuck: To have sneaked; to move, past tense, in a sneaky manner; non-restrictive extended semi-gerundial form of "did sneak."
(We think.)
ghost car:An unmarked police car, easily identifiable by its inconspicuousness.
impaired:A charge of drunk driving. Used both as a noun and as an adjective(the alternative adjectival from of "impaired" being "pissed to the gills").
S.O.L.: Shit outta luck; in an unfortunate predicament.
Stanfields: Men's underwear, especially Grandpa-style, white cotton ones with a big elastic waistband and a large superfluous flap in the front. And back!
toque: Canada's official National Head Apparel, with about the same suave sex appeal as a pair of Stanfields.
chippy: Behaviour that is inappropriately aggressive; constantly looking for a reason to find offense; from "chip on one's shoulder." (See Western Canada)
shit disturber: (See Quebec) a troublemaker or provocateur. According to Katherine Barber, editor in Chief of the Canadian Oxford Dictionary, "shit disturber" is a distinctly Canadian term. (Just remember that Western Canada is chippy and Quebec is a shit disturber, and you will do fine.)
Sorry, eh.

*I can't take credit for this one, but thought you might enjoy.

Thursday, November 01, 2007

Synthetic biology

One of the hazards of the kind of dissertation I'm doing - one that engages with contemporary literature based on emerging technologies - is that there's always new technologies emerging that have an impact on the literature being produced. And that means there's always something new I'm learning about.

Take Synthetic Biology.

I actually hadn't even heard the term until a couple of weeks ago, just before the whole James-Watson-discoverer-of-DNA-is-a-racist thing blew up in his face. Frankly, I think the man made a big mistake making the comments he did - first because they smack of racism, and secondly (and more importantly), that because he's a scientist, people assume he's speaking from a scientific perspective - which he's not. But that's a whole different issue - the link above will give you a good idea of the nature of Watson's comments.

Synthetic biology is an interesting extension of transgenics, and it is moving human beings much, much closer to the science fiction scenarios in the books I'm writing about for the dissertation.

From the ETC report (PDF) on Synthetic Biology "Extreme Genetic Engineering: An Introduction to Synthetic Biology":
Transgenics, the kind of engineering you find in genetically modified tomatoes and corn, is old news. As recombinant DNA splicing-techniques turn 30 years old, a new generation of extreme biotech enthusiasts have moved to the next frontier in the manipulation of life: building it from scratch. They call it synthetic biology.
Essentially, genetic engineering is the alteration of existing organisms, while synthetic biology is the creation of new organisms from scratch. The report goes on to describe synthetic biology as "the design and construction of new biological parts, devices and systems that do not exist in the natural world and also the redesign of existing biological systems to perform specific tasks" and that the technologies that allow this design and construction are becoming readily and cheaply available to anyone with a laptop, some knowledge of genetic engineering and a few dollars.

Synthetic biology is interesting to me for two reasons. First, because it is a controversial topic that will require social input into policy production (and that policy will need to be more globally oriented than nationally oriented since the scientific community transcends national considerations and since globalization means that anyone anywhere can get ahold of the materials needed for synthetic biology). Proponents of synthetic biology, the most prominent of whom is J. Craig Venter (quite a character by all accounts), point to the humanitarian solutions to problems that synthetic biology brings. Producing medicines, like those needed for malaria treatment, or bio-fuels through synthetic organisms does indeed have the potential to solve some of the most pressing public health and environmental problems that the world faces today.

But producing beneficial drugs and other solutions to human-made problems is accompanied by a darker potential offered by synthetic biology, and that is the potential to create biological weapons or synthetic organisms that are harmful to human beings on this planet. Just as we have had to do for preceeding technologies (e.g. nuclear energy and weapons), humanity has to come to some sort of consensus about the appropriate use of these technologies and how to regulate them.

Not only am I interested in the development of public policy regarding synthetic biology as a human occupying a space on this planet, but it also impacts the discussion of genetic engineering and other emergent technologies (AI, alife, genomics, nanotechnology, robotics) that emerges in the novels that I'm examining in the dissertation. So it's both my life, and my life, so to speak, that are at stake.

This is in part the second reason that I'm interested in synthetic biology. Synthetic biology offers the means to produce the kinds of people/organisms/beings found in the science fiction novels I'm examining. In other words, synthetic biology, and associated technologies like nanotech, alife, and robotics could create the kinds of humans that right now only exist in science fiction. It could turn science fiction into science fact.

This transformation is the reason why science fiction theorists exist. Science fiction offers readers the opportunity to look into a potential future and decide whether it's a future they want or not. Certainly many of the scenarios imagined in past science fiction adventures have not come to pass. But in some cases I have to wonder if that's simply because history took a different turn, or because someone read a science fiction story that sounded a warning about a society we might not want to create and turned away from an avenue that would have led there.

So synthetic biology interests me as a human who will live in a world where it will become more and more prevalent, and it interests me as someone who studies literature that has already imagined what synthetic biology might produce.

And from what I've seen of the literature, even benign uses of synthetic biology have some negative and unpleasant consequences. But that also is another post.

Closely related to synthetic biology is posthumanism (or transhumanism or extropianism - they're all variations of a similar sentiment even though some within the movements very vehemently draw lines between them). Posthumanism tries to imagine what human beings could look like in the future, as we develop various technologies (robotics, alife, nanotechnology, genetic engineering etc.) that have the potential to change the nature of the human from a fully organic organism to a technologically-mediated one.

One of my first encounters with the ideas of posthumanism was with the Lifeboat Foundation, which appears at different times to be part crack-pot and part rational voice in the wilderness. I suppose that's what happens when you get enough people together that have the same goal, but different ideas about how to get there.

Posthumanists generally embrace the idea that humans will change, with the often unstated assumption that this change will be for the better. They have embraced some of the stranger manifestations of this - e.g. cyrogenics, but they have also encouraged researchers in more prosaic areas of endeavour, such as weather management and storm control.

For the most part, Lifeboat is more supportive of synthetic biology than ETC, though I think the difference has more to do with organizational structure and funding than with the relative assessment of risk associated with synthetic biology. Whether the general population embraces it or fears it, there will need to be public discussion of the technology in order to control it, and the sooner that happens, the better (both for my life and my dissertation!)

Tuesday, October 30, 2007

Still thinking about humans

I'm still thinking about "more human than human" especially after such great comments from everyone. Thanks!

I sat in the airport this weekend thinking about it, not just because of White Zombie, but because I thought it might be a worthwhile thing to think about.

At first, I rationalized that figuring out what "more human than human" means would require defining "human" first. But I also quickly realized that defining what makes a human, human in the first place would require a really long answer... say, dissertation length.

But then I rationalized that the reverse might be just as productive. If I were to examine the answers to what "more human than human" looks like, those answers might reveal the assumptions on which those answers are based. After all, in order to answer the question, you have to have some idea what "human" is in order to imagine what could transcend the human to become "more".

So I started thinking about it. The music video features a lot of kids in costumes, with the most frequent costumes being a pumpkin head and a robot. While in the live show, the huge creature wandering the stage is more alien looking. (I posted the best clip I could find from Youtube - and yes, that's actually the best one)

The first thought that came into my mind when I saw the thing in the stage show we attended was that it looked a bit like a homunculus. Not a lot, but a bit. More so like the sensory homunculus that is supposed to represent the brain's designated spaces for bodily sensations.

What both homunculi have in common is an overly large head, and the sensory homunculus has very long arms. I think that's what caught my attention the most with the big monster/alien thing at the Zombie show. But that's beside the point.

Zombie's answer to what is more human than human is an alien or a monster. And that got me thinking that the monster just might be more human than human.

Part of what makes the monster monstrous is exactly that it is "more". It's not more "human" than humans, but it's certainly "more" than human. Monsters either have more limbs, or eyes, or larger heads, or even just larger bodies overall. Their bodies tend to be "more" than human bodies are, which is what actually makes them monstrous.

Then I got to thinking about the novels I've been reading and realizing that many of the clones and cyborgs in them are monstrous in just this way - they are "more" than human. So maybe Zombie's answer of "monster" to the question of what is more human than human isn't so far off. Maybe what really makes us human is what unacademic advisor and rebeckler suggest in the comments below, that it is our frailty and our failings that make us human. To be "more human than human" is simply a construction we hold up that fails to provide us with a guideline about what it means to be human because it expects more from us than we are capable of. And that more is itself monstrous.

But I think in proposing that, I'm waxing philosophic in a way that would not be useful in a literary dissertation. But it's fun to think about, and has served the function of organizing some of my thinking about the topic and about the books I'm reading. In helping me organize my scattered thoughts, there is indeed much good.

I still am not sure about the robot in the music video though... that might be another post. Any thoughts?

Oh, and in answer to my question/suggestion last week: yes, a couple of days of sunshine and warm weather have made me feel less cheated about our short summer. Now I'm ready for fall and winter to arrive.

Rob Zombie More Human Than Human Live

Short clip from a live performance

White Zombie - More Human Than Human

The images in this video are more robotic than the images in the live show

Friday, October 26, 2007

Viva!

I'm running off this weekend to a place where I can wear dresses without needing tights, and can even wear shorts during the daytime. I can't wait!

I don't write this to make people envious - I know how it feels when other people are taking off for fun vacations in warm places and you're stuck at home, and it's not a nice feeling. But I am writing it because I'm looking forward to it. The last few months have been much more hectic than I would've expected them to be if you'd asked me about them at the beginning of the summer.

And August here was so wet and cool that it didn't feel like summer at all. Not to mention that the month was eaten up by moving and such. So I'm hoping a dose of sun AND warmth this weekend will dispell the feeling that I somehow missed summer this year. I'll have to let you know when I get back whether it worked...!

Wednesday, October 24, 2007

More human than human

Friends, readers, curious bypassers...

What image does this phrase bring to mind? What could be "more human than human"? If I asked you this question, what would your answer be?

Tuesday, October 23, 2007

Impatient yet overloaded

I get to go away this weekend... which I'm very much looking forward to doing.

But in the meantime, I've got lots to do.

Which I don't really want to do.

I want the weekend to come soon, but I need it to wait so that I can finish off everything that needs to be done this week.

Two equal but opposite desires...

Thursday, October 18, 2007

Hangin' out with the smart kids

I knew leaving my colleagues far behind and trying to write a dissertation from afar would be a challenge. But I thought it would be a challenge to stay focused, not that it might make me stupider.

Well, not really more stupid, but less articulate at least. I've been listening to Malcolm Gladwell's Blink, in which he proposes that split-second decisions can be the most accurate. He calls this rapid cognition and it results from something he calls the thin-slicing of experience. The reason thin-slicing and gut instinct can yield some of the most accurate information on which to base decisions is because they are processed subconsciously. For example, he found that gamblers playing a rigged game responded physiologically to the rig (sweaty palms, indicating increased stress) before they consciously figured out that the game was rigged.

This subconscious attention to the world also affects our interaction with it. In an experiment, researchers gave two groups of people 30 trivial pursuit questions to answer. Just before they were to answer the questions, the first group was told to think about what it would be like to work as a professor, while the second group were told to think about soccer hooligans.

Just thinking about intelligence (presumably a requisite to being a professor) yielded 55.6% correct answers in the first group, while thinking about a lack of intelligence (again, presumably a requisite for being a soccer hooligan) yielded correct answers only 42.6% of the time. Wow.

It wasn't just intelligence either. Test subjects given a linguistic test that included a high number of words having to do with aging walked slower after exiting the test room, and those with words about rudeness and agression were ruder to the examiner upon leaving.

So... maybe it would be of benefit to hang out with smart people... to think of myself as one of them... to admire how smart they really are.

Certainly couldn't hurt.

But I've left my academic community far behind, and try as I might, I don't belong to the ones here.

Might have more of a negative impact than I originally thought...

Wednesday, October 17, 2007

Tidbits

*I began this post almost a week ago before things went really hairy around here, so I'll give you the beginning and continue on from that point.

The bone marrow people think I'm a low risk donor, so they've decided that I'll move on to the testing phase of pre-screening. This means I have to go have blood drawn next week, which surprises me because this whole process has already taken a few weeks. I would've thought it would be faster since the sooner someone receives a transplant, the better, right?

William Gibson looks like a hippie farmer. Now, it's true that I've seen pictures of him before. But I'd never seen him in person till last night, and he looks and moves a bit like a hippie, and a bit like a farmer. I've met a few farmers before, and they have that same kind of look haunting their faces - I'd always thought it was a result of the unreliability of their business. After all, for a farmer, no matter how savvy a businessman you are, you're still at the mercy of the weather to some extent. This seemed to always inject a look that was one part concern, one part resignation into their faces.

But maybe I don't really know farmers that well. All I know is that Gibson had that same kind of look and could've passed for a praire farmer except for the retro-vintage Converse on his feet. Oh, and his writing is really cool!

One of these days I'd like to take a computer course that would explain to me in a bit more detail how this machine that I use every day, that I sometimes feel chained to, that frustrates me to no end at times, works. Just as I was starting this post, I ran into a problem that kept shutting down some of the functions of my system.

Now, I'm not afraid of trying to fix stuff myself, so since web access wasn't one of the problems, I googled the error message. The most prominent answer was that I'd picked up a virus, but as I kept reading, the only "people" claiming this was a problem were all pointing me to the same software - that I could purchase for the low, low price of $49.95 - that I could buy. So I had to wonder about that one, especially since I run virus scans fairly regularly with a product that I've been using successfully for years.

The other solution to the problem was to enter the registry and delete the files that had corruped. Now, I've actually done this before, even though for a non-techie person like me this is a scary venture, but I had a good set of instructions from several sources (including MS themselves) and it was successful. Only this time, the only instructions included were to erase a particular kind of file, whose designation was not provided. This meant I could go into the registry, but I'd have no clear idea which files I should delete. Not something I'm ready to mess with.

Logically, reformatting the hard drive to original specification should restore the corrupted files in their original form, yes? Yes. It did. But it also meant I had to back up all my data files, then reload them all (a process not quite complete) as well as reload all the additional software that I use (another process not quite complete). In consequence, I have been uploading but not producing much for the last few days. I guess there isn't an interesting observation there. Just some kvetching.


I have a greater appreciation for the time and care that goes into the production of a television show, or any other video production. Over the weekend, we shot a 20 minute segment for one of our elearning programs. It took about 10 1/2 hours.

Of course on a tv show, there are multiple cameras, so that if you change locations, you don't have to haul one set of lights, camera, monitor, associated cables, power units etc. to the new location as we did, which would make the process faster. And you would easily access backup equipment if a malfunction happened instead of having to drive across town to check that the equipment was indeed working. So we might have been able to finish a bit faster, but not by much. It is certainly a time-consuming production.

It was also really neat to see two professionals interacting in that kind of work environment. The talent and the cameraman we used had worked together before (in fact the talent was the person who recommended the cameraman to us), and the easy shorthand that they fell into was fascinating to watch. Perhaps it's just that film still holds a fascination for me that I was so impressed, but I was.

We're nearing the end of our semester at work (yes, we're off kilter from every other institution around us), which means students are starting to get desperate. I have one who is trying to do 10 weeks worth of work in 2 to catch up. Every time before this when students have tried to catch up like this, they've failed. But this guy just might make it - a week in and he's still on track. I'm rooting for him to do it, if for no other reason than to restore my faith in the human ability to transcend difficulties. Other students however are asking for bonus assignments to make up work done 6 weeks ago. Maybe I'm a hard ass, but I'm saying no. I've got better things to do than dream up additional work for them when they should've done the original stuff.

There you go. That's part of what's been going on lately. But it looks like things will slow down now, so I'll post a bit more often, at least for a little while...

Monday, October 15, 2007

Long hiatus

For those two readers (maybe three?) who regularly pay attention to this blog, this is just to assure you that I have not suffered any mortal trauma or anything equally dramatic. Just life which has conspired to keep me out of the blogsphere.

And now I see that Blogger is going to be down later today, so you might not get an update, but it will come eventually.

Transformer CellPhone

Some people obviously have a lot of time on their hands... I gotta wonder what those guns shoot...

Friday, October 05, 2007

Scholarly pursuits

There's been a scholarly conference in town this week. Although I didn't submit something to present, I signed up to attend because I'd been feeling like this dissertation from afar was leaving me without scholarly camraderie.

I've gotta say it's been really nice to sit in a room full of people who like the kinds of things I like and listen to them say intelligent things (and even get up the nerve to ask a (hopefully) intelligent question!)

But I also found myself distracted and annoyed at times.

Does it make me a bad scholar if my mind wanders during a particularly uninteresting presentation? Or am I only a bad scholar if in my wandering I ponder the next hockey game?

Am I just picky, or should I be annoyed that the person reading his paper at the front of the room is pausing to pick up his pen and make numerous grammatical corrections to it as he reads? I don't really mind the occasional tick in the margin, but if you're correcting three or four errors per page, I get the feeling you don't think the session is very important to you, and then I wonder why I'm taking the time to come listen to you!

And I've discovered, or solidified, a conference peeve - film scholars who can't be bothered to calculate that the five minute clip plus five minutes of fumbling with the technology actually adds ten minutes to their fifteen minute presentation. Especially when all four of them do it!

When you think of it, some of the things these very intelligent people do are really rather funny... but not in the ha-ha kind of way.

Tuesday, October 02, 2007

Discovery or coincidence?

Today I left home five minutes later than usual but got to work at the same time. Is it just coincidence and traffic was just lighter than usual today? Or have I discovered that I can get five minutes extra sleep every morning? I'd love for it to be the latter...

Monday, October 01, 2007

What is natural?

I've been trying to organize some of my research over the last several months into parts of a chapter that needs to get written and am discovering I have a linguistic problem I'll need to tackle.

What is natural?

In a common sense kind of way, we know what natural means. We know that "all-natural" cold medicines won't contain drugs that have had to go through strict testing (and thus are potent kinds of body altering substances). We know that "natural" childbirth as opposed to assisted also means no drugs are administered. We also know that "natural" on food ingredients is a signal that they have not been genetically modified, or had pesticides or herbicides applied to them (at least not ones that, again, require some kind of regulation for their production, sale and use).

But even that last paragraph starts to demonstrate the problem. We intuitively know what's natural and what's not, but when you start to actually define it, things get a bit fuzzier.

My dissertation is about emerging technologies that offer the possibility of altering humans. I usually don't finish that sentence, but I could certainly add "from their natural state." But what is that natural state?

If I take pseudoephedrine for a head cold, I feel like my brain doesn't function "naturally" and that I have a harder time recalling things or concentrating. So is the pseudoephedrine unnatural? But isn't the infection of my sinuses by a virus also unnatural? In the effort to restore my sinuses to 'normal' functioning, my brain feels like it's operating unnaturally. [I've had a cold this week, how can you tell?] Is the absense of infection or drugs to counter it the only natural state possible? A head cold is one thing, but what about a chronic condition?

Is disease natural?

Human disease is a part of the human condition. I'm not thinking individually here. From the individual's perspective, the development of a disease is unnatural. But from a species perspective, disease is a natural part of the human condition, just as is death. If I could engineer myself to never succumb to a disease, would that be natural or unnatural? What if everyone could be engineered to be immune to all diseases. Would that then be natural? Is it a case of the majority getting to define natural?

The question will be most pertinent when I come to the section on pharmacological visions of posthumanity. If I can take a memory-boosting drug, am I unnatural? If we had such a drug, would we have to test for it before exams like we do for steroids before athletic competitions? What about the argument that we should stop testing for steroids because it's just becoming the new norm? Would the same apply to drugs that alter our brains?

But there are things that affect our brains and how well they work. Vitamin deficiencies or malnutrition will result in stunted brain development. We can't really call that normal can we? But if we administered a drug that would counteract that retardation of development, would that then be normal? Can two unnatural acts equal to a natural state?

You see how confused I am getting?

Or perhaps I'm just making it a bigger problem than it really is.

Perhaps there's a way of writing an entire dissertation without using the word "normal"... but I doubt it. Even if I avoid the word itself, the concept is still a slippery one that I'll have to get a handle on.

Enhancements are another part of dissertation that run into the same kind of problems. In their most basic definition, cyborgs are a combination of flesh and machine. We know what the Terminator looks like, or the Borg, but what about things a little closer to home? Is a cochlear implant or a pacemaker a cyborg technology? They're both machine implanted in flesh. But neither are highly visible, so it's easy to "pass" as a natural human.

But Andy Clark makes the argument that our tools are enhancements of our natural abilities as well. So when I am wielding a tool, am I being unnatural? The common sense answer is no. What if that tool is implanted in my body like Kevin Warwick's implant? Is that still a natural? Or is the penetration of the body what makes it unnatural? You see where this is leading? What if I don't implant a mechanical device in my body but I use a drug that permanently changes my abilities. It's not unnatural like an implant, but common sense would say that a permanent change is unnatural. But I could also enact other permanent changes in my body, like weight gain for example. Is that natural or unnatural? What about a scar? Is it natural or unnatural? I might not have been born with it, but in the course of my body's natural repairing function, I might develop one.

One of the questions the dissertation asks is: how much change can the human body undergo until we begin to question whether it is a human body? The Terminator is easy to classify, but in the stages up until that point, a boundary has to be crossed at some point. I'm suspecting that what we define as a 'natural' human being might be the point at which we draw that boundary, which is why I'm trying to figure out what I might mean when I think of the 'natural' human being and an 'unnatural' one.

Friday, September 28, 2007

The RCMP always get their man...

... or in this case, their woman.

I picked up the mail the other day to find an envelope from the RCMP. My first thought was that I'd managed to pick up a multanova ticket. But then I realized I hadn't taken my car out of the city for weeks, so it couldn't be that.

I was intensely curious when I opened the envelope.

Turns out the RCMP were helping the Canadian Blood Services track people down. It seems that I'm a potential match for the Unrelated Bone Marrow Donor Program. I was surprised since I'd first signed up for the program probably a decade ago - in fact they have me in the system under my old name.

So there's a questionnaire, and then if everything matches up on it, some additional testing. Right now they say I'm a 60% match, which doesn't sound like it would actually be much good, but apparently it's close enough that they're doing the followup.

It's one of those kinds of things that you don't really expect to happen - a bit like jury duty perhaps (which I've actually managed to avoid till this point in my life) - so it was a real surprise to get the call. I don't know how I feel about it. If I am a match, I could really help someone. But if I'm not a match, I avoid what I understand is a very painful procedure.

I guess I'll just have to wait and see what happens.

Tuesday, September 25, 2007

Doing what you're supposed to

Confessions of a Community College Dean - a very good blog if you haven't come across it before - recently had a post about not doing what you're "supposed" to do with your degree.

I think it's possible before your degree to not do what you're supposed to do either. (Of course I think this because I do not yet have my degree.)

Not doing what you're "supposed" to in your academic career seems to be what I've been doing myself.

In my second year of course work, I attended a faculty-sponsored seminar in which we were explicitly told that it was not worth going to conferences or publishing unless we did it at the very best conferences and with the very best names. I found the talk disheartening, wondering how someone like me could ever get the very best names and places to pay attention to me.

But then I went on my merry way. I attended my second PCA/ACA conference later that year and had a great time. I met all kinds of neat people - established scholars, professors, and graduate students - who liked to study popular culture and I knew I'd found my niche. The warnings of that seminar lurked in the back of my brain, but I was enjoying the study of pop culture so much that I tended to push the warning back to the nether regions of my brain. (Not to mention the advice was doled out by the same individual who told me studying film was a waste of time... even though I already knew several people who were building promising careers around the study of film)

At my first PCA, my advisor recommended me and I presented part of a chapter from my MA thesis. For the second PCA, I returned even further into the past to resurrect my honors thesis from undergrad. See, at the time I'd written the thesis, the novel series I was writing on had only reached volume #4, but by the time second PCA rolled around, the full 7 volume set had been produced, and in paperback. I'd always wanted to revisit the work I'd done once the series was complete, and this seemed the perfect opportunity.

The paper went really well; the panel was even better; and getting to know the scholars working in the area was an even better experience. For third PCA, I presented on a different topic with a different group, but I hung out with the gang from the previous year for dinner and again enjoyed myself. PCA number four had me working with some of the same people in a different area.

So as the deadline for abstract submissions for my fifth PCA approaches, I'm again thinking of the networks I've connected with. I'm working hard on trying to figure out a paper that emerges from the dissertation to submit instead of working up something entirely new.

But the point of the story is that the panel chair for that second PCA convention just emailed me. She's signed a book collection deal, and remembering my presentation, has indicated she would like to include that paper in the book.

How cool is that?!

Okay, if you're not in academia, you might not think that's cool. But belive me, it's way cool!

By embracing this pop cultural connection, I may be eliminating myself from the upper echelons of academia; the Shakespeareans and the Classicists and other similar scholars may no longer want me in their clubs. I realize I'm painting myself into a niche which - like the careers of some movie stars - might be hard to break out of. But, you know, I'm enjoying the work I'm doing. And if you don't enjoy your chosen career, then what's the point? I'm beginning to suspect that I just might be comfortable building a career on the academic B-list.

Monday, September 24, 2007

A concert and a dodge

The Blue man Group is a very cool concert. The irony that I see them this weekend, in a place very far from their any of their home bases is not lost on me. Partially because I had to drive several hours to see them. But most especially because I lived in a regular show city and never ever saw them when I lived there. Mostly because there was always something more pressing that I needed to spend the ticket money on.

We began the long drive home, fairly late at night, down a four lane highway that we've both driven many times before. This highway is fairly busy, even late at night, so there were plenty of on coming headlights from the other side of the meridian to keep us awake and such.

Suddenly, about half way home, we came around a corner and the headlights coming at us seemed unusually bright. My first thought was that they were those new halogen type headlights - the ones that are so bright I wonder how they can be legal since they essentially blind all the other drivers on the road, something I think would be a hazardous condition that shouldn't be encouraged. But then the angle wasn't quite right, so I thought it was maybe a car on a crossroad, or a side road, whose headlights were coming at us at such a strange angle.

By the time we both realized that the headlights looked so bright and at such a strange angle, we were side by side with the vehicle, who was travelling the opposite direction in our left lane.

Shocked would be an understatement.

My first thought was for the car we had just passed, who was still behind us and who the driver travelling the wrong way up the highway would soon encounter. But when we turned to watch, it was apparent we were the clue that sunk in because the minivan was braking and pulling off the road. So at least there wasn't going to be an accident as a result of this person's wrong way driving.

That was a relief.

Realizing that we were lucky we weren't in the left passing lane was another relief.

I've always wondered when hearing about head on collisions in good weather why they happen. Living in a part of the world where most highways are straight and wide, and you can see oncoming traffic, often for miles, I wonder how people are unable to avoid such collisions.

But now I know.

We met this wrong-travelling vehicle coming out of a turn at the top of a hill. So we didn't see his headlights for long before our respective 110kph speeds rapidly ate up the distance between us. Because we were on a curve, it was also a little harder to determine the angles between us, the oncoming vehicle, and the position of our side of the road at the point where we saw his headlights.

But one of the biggest things that I suspect leads to head on accidents, even in clear weather is plain old disbelief. My brain generated a number of other explanations for the odd looking headlights when I first saw them. It was only when the other possibilities had been eliminated and it became evident that it had to be the unthinkable - that a car was driving the wrong way on the highway toward us - that my brain accepted that possibility and acted upon it.

Because let's face it, we've all had that experience of seeing lights on a crossroad, or a flash of light off a side window, or a shadow that has made us think there's a vehicle there that isn't, or that it's travelling differently than it actually is. (On a road trip one time, all three of us driving kept thinking there was a car in our blind spot when we'd shoulder check because the stupid rental car company had plastered a sticker on the rear side window and we kept thinking it was an object outside the car) It's just a momentary flash, but it happens often enough, that we doubt our own senses.

Seeing headlights coming toward you as your round a curve, the first thought is that it must be a trick of the light, as has happened at other times before. It's only when the visual evidence continues to mount that you realize this is indeed a situation that is out of the ordinary and the unthinkable could happen in the next moment. I can imagine that for some people, the realization that the unthinkable is indeed going to happen comes too late and they cannot avoid the collision.

Complacency and the belief that everything is progressing normally saves us from braking for things that aren't there (which would make us look like doofuses), but it also slows down our acceptance of the things that are there, especially when they shouldn't be.

Friday, September 21, 2007

Kids taking charge... in pink

This news story about a couple of teens who took action against bullies in their school is fabulous!

The students were reacting to an incident on the first day of school when a new student was harrassed and threatened for wearing a pink shirt. David Shephard and Travis Price, a couple of grade 12 students, went out and bought 75 pink shirts to hand out to students to send a signal to the bullies that their behaviour wasn't acceptable.

Now apparently there are several other schools in Nova Scotia where kids are undertaking similar "wear pink" days to protest bullying.

The greatest part about the whole thing is that this isn't adults telling kids what's good and what's not - it's the students who have spearheaded this campaign to stop the bullying. If bullies are ostracized for their behaviour, it will rapidly dampen the effect. It's when no one objects that bullying flourishes. That the students took on this problem is worth far more than all the PSAs produced about it.

Thursday, September 20, 2007

Teeny, tiny cars

I read today in the newspaper that downtown Calgary is switching to an electronic pay system for parking downtown.

The rationale behind pulling out parking meters in favor of this new system is that people aren't constrained by where the meters are actually located. Rather, if you can find the space, you've got it. This idea is not new. One of my students proposed this revamp to parking in Boston several years ago. (Of course in Boston, this strategy is already employed in practice where you frequently see three cars occupying the space allocated to two meters.)

The theory is that you can fit more cars into the same space. Preliminary results here bear out the theory, though of course once we get several feet of snow, that might change.

Driving a car that requires less than 3m of parking space, means that if I can squeeze in, it's mine! Since I take up less than half the room of a halfton truck and many SUVs, that means I've got more options for parking than I ever did before. The university has switched to a similar park-if-you-can-fit-in strategy at some of its meters, which I discovered this morning on the monthly research run to the library.

There's also a rumor, not in the article I've linked to, but in the paper version of the paper that *certain* smaller vehicles and motorcycles will also recieve a 25% discount on parking when they register with the system. Double bonus!

Wednesday, September 19, 2007

Cats, chimeras and DNA

In Free Culture, Lawrence Lessig argues that what makes us human is our DNA. Writing about chimeras – people and other organisms with two sets of DNA because two embryos fused during development – he writes, “the very idea of DNA is that it is the code of an individual. Yet in fact, not only can two individuals have the same set of DNA (identical twins), but one person can have two different sets of DNA (a chimera). Our understanding of a ‘person’ should reflect this reality”. It is important to note that Lessig’s claim that our understanding of “person” should take into account the possibility that they do not have a single unique sequence of DNA rests on an assumption that DNA is what defines the human as such. His claim for DNA as the code of the individual is widely accepted, but DNA is also the code for individual animals, just the same as it is for humans. Consider for a moment that that DNA of an individual housecat differs from other housecats. Each household pet could be identified forensically by their DNA, just as we do in for humans in crime scenes. To find a cat that is a chimera, with two sets of DNA, would not lead us to question whether that cat is indeed a cat.

But according to Lessig, the human chimera should be taken into consideration when defining the human as an individual with a unique and single DNA signature. How is it that the category of person is challenged by the chimera, while the category of cat is not?

I guess I'm not necessarily expecting an answer - it's just a question that emerged from the reading.

Monday, September 17, 2007

Country and City

I've been spending a lot of time driving across vast expanses of prairie (or similar landscape) over the recent months and it's gotten me thinking about rural and urban spaces. I've also moved from a small urban space to a much larger one, and it has got me noticing the differences.

All of this has reconfirmed for me that I am a big city gal at heart.

It's not that I love the congestion and the sometimes lack of privacy that a large urban center offers. Nor is it that I don't like the friendliness that a smaller town or city can offer. It's mostly the amenities that come with an urban center that exceeds a certain size that makes me like the big city.

I've lived in all kinds of places. From a small hamlet of under 300 to a sprawling metropolis of 15 million. Now, I will grant that the huge metropolis can be intimidating, and there certainly are downsides to such a huge place. Transportation becomes more difficult and in some neighborhoods can be downright dangerous. You don't even need to be a metropolis for that to occur. But even though getting around might be a bit harder, you've usually also got a lot more options.

Whereas living in a little hamlet, transportation isn't a problem - the whole place is only about 10 square blocks. But to do any business, you need to travel to a larger center, and getting there can sometimes be a problem. Not to mention everyone knows everyone else's business. There is something slightly consoling about the anonmymity of the city, knowing that if you have a bad day and don't feel like smiling, it's not going to start a rumour about how bad your life is - there's a good chance no one you meet on a day like that will remember you.

But mostly I like the amenities that come with a larger city. Take the one I live in now. In the next month, there's a film festival, a book festival, two concerts I want to see, and an academic conference in my field that will be held here. In a smaller place, I'd have to travel to get that - and then I would be travelling, not able to retreat home after each event. It also is large enough to boast several playhouses, a decent music scene, and a variety of restaurants and clubs that will not leave you wanting when the mood hits for something specific.

And decent public transit if I want/need it.

In a smaller urban center, or in a rural one, there certainly are more people who "know your name" and who you can count on to remember you and to say hi as you pass. In a larger place, there's a lot less of that. But what you don't get from your neighbors, you can still find. There are far more people available to connect with - to find people who share the same interests isn't difficult, and so you create your social networks not out of proximity, but because you share the same interests or values.

It's a bit like social networking on the internet - in all its formats, not just the most recent incarnations - from usenet groups to facebook - you can find someone else with whom you share an interest in almost anything. Sometimes that's good. Sometimes it's not. But I like the idea of having a lot of strangers around me, some of whom will make good friends when I get to know them. Yes, I suppose I pay a price because I could become more isolated within a sea of people, but then again, when I went to blend into that sea, I can dive in and no one will take notice. Then I can go home and call on the network I've created out of that sea. In some ways, there's a certain level of comfort to be taken in that.

Saturday, September 15, 2007

Creepy people

I first ran across the idea expressed in this article The Undead Zone: Why realistic graphics makes humans look creepy when I was reading Scott McLeod's Understanding Comics. The author even mentions McLeod in the discussion.

The essence of the article is that we are comfortable with humanoid creatures, in video games or even robotics, but once they get too be human-looking, we focus on the 1% that isn't quite right and get creeped out by it. Of course Freud's unheimlich is the same kind of thing as well.

Today I walked into the living room while a sports show was on television. And just for a moment, the two athletes on the screen looked like CGI characters, not real humans. I felt that kind of creepiness when I thought they were CGI-ed. But when I realized they weren't CGI'ed, that's when they just got a whole lot creepier.

I felt sorry for men who would go through life resembling CGI characters because of their physical features. And then I started wondering if perhaps I had only made that mistake because they were athletes - you know, muscled bodies, few physical defects etc. Both happened to be pale red-heads too, and I wonder if that had something to do with it. After all, the most realistically CGI-ed characters in video games tend to be white, don't they?

I haven't really thought it all out yet, but it got me thinking about the reverse of what the article is talking about. What happens when we think the humans look unrealistic? Is it the same effect as when CGI-ed characters look too human? Something to think about a bit more perhaps...

Wednesday, September 12, 2007

Finally starting to swim...

... or at the very least, finally keeping my head above water...

...seeing the light at the end of the tunnel...

...emerging from a under the weight of a mammoth to do list.

(pick the phrase you like the best)

I don't know that I'm back on track - I suspect my sense that things are improving is simple self-delusion and wishful thinking. But I do know that I feel much better today about where I stand in relation to all my obligations and commitments. So I'll take the good feelings when I can!

Moving of course is one of those things that eats up incredibly huge amounts of time. It's not just the packing up of all your stuff, the loading it in a truck, the driving it (probably the shortest moving-related activity this time) or the unloading it. It's all the other stuff that goes with moving. The cleaning up of the old place. The fixing of old and/or new place. The changing registrations of cars, schools, utlities, taxes, blah, blah, blah...

But the moving is mostly over. There are a lot of places that don't have a change of address yet - I'm relying on the forwarding to keep me in touch. So that still needs to be done. And there are several boxes that still need unpacking. But life has mostly settled down.

Before the move, I had my classes prepped for two weeks in advance (minus marking of course). Those two weeks got eaten up awfully fast and I was left scrambling the night before a couple of times. I'm working on rebuilding that lead and can say I'm actually getting there. So that's becoming one less thing hanging over my head.

There were a few birthdays following right on the tail of the moving. And I had to finish editing a paper for a deadline. A couple more things - pleasant - but nonetheless requiring time, that kept me busy for what felt like every hour of the day. There's still another paper to edit. Oh, yeah, and that dissertation thing-y to write. But I'm feeling a bit more caught up now, which is nice.

Long and short of it is that there should be more posting - at least a bit more - from now until it all falls apart again...

Saturday, September 08, 2007

Singin' in the rain


Sometimes we don't pay attention to the good things in life. It's the annoyances and irritations that get all the headlines.

But over the last two days, we've had showers on an off. On Thursday, I wasn't expecting them and was wearing a sundress with a cute but not really functional sweater, so when it started to rain as I drove away from work, I anticipated cold dashes through rain to the errands I had to complete. When the sleet started, I really got depressed.

But by the time I arrived at my errands, the rain let up. And only restarted when I got home.

Same thing Friday. Rain while driving home. None once I got out of the car to go into the grocery store.

Sometimes I just forget that luck does occasionally go my way. Sure, rain is a small thing, but sometimes, it might be all you have. I'm thankful for how the rain coincided with my schedule the last couple of days.

Thursday, August 30, 2007

A matter of style?*

Editing another person’s work and having your own work edited by someone else is an interesting project. Two different people’s writing styles and habits come into contact with each other in the editing process, and the question then becomes, “whose style wins out?”

I suppose a precursor question to that one is “what constitutes style?”

Everyone has their own way of doing things. This of course extends to writing as well. But there are different levels of expertise in writing too. Some people are better at it than others. So how do you tell the difference between an editor’s suggestion coming from the fact that they are better at what they do than you, and when it is just a stylistic preference?

In my MA thesis, my the members of my committee were provided with copies of the thesis before my defense, and of course after the defense, they each had suggestions for things that needed to be done before they would accept the thesis as complete. Most of the suggestions were about content, but one of my committee members had covered the pages of the thesis in commas. She was suggesting throughout the thesis that my commas were not properly placed.

I started editing the thesis, inserting all those commas in, but stopped halfway through because I realized that this was just a stylistic difference. Her writing used more commas than mine, but it wasn’t any more “right” than my style of writing. (Of course commas are the most flexible form of punctuation to use and styles range from almost nothing to insertion between every phrase.) In that case, the suggested comma inserts were a stylistic difference and by not inserting them, I don’t think I produced a poorer quality thesis.

But now I’m faced with a similar editing comment. I’ve been told my style in employing citations is faulty. It wasn’t that the MLA citation style was wrong; the comment was that I don’t do enough to set up quotations before inserting them into my writing. The suggestion for changing it felt artificial to me, like how you set up quotations when you’re first learning how to do so, but the advice was coming from a good place, so I took a look at my citations.

Now at first I accepted this advice and revised the way I embedded citations in my writing. But what’s making me wonder if this is simply a stylistic difference is that I’ve been reading other people’s writing, and realized that there is a wide variation in writing. In particular I’m reading Walter Benjamin, who was really big on citation. He seems to employ citation in a way similar to how I do, but contrary to how my editor indicated it should be done.

The quoting changes have already been made, and I’m happy to leave then as such in the essay, but now I’m left puzzling over whether I need to work on this, or whether it is just a stylistic difference for the next time I sit down to write something. I really don’t know.

*blog post originally written Aug 24th.

Wednesday, August 29, 2007

*breathing a (small) sigh of relief*

We are moved. Or as my husband says, "now all our crap is in our giant, expensive crap-holder."

Thursday, August 23, 2007

The tao of moving

Posting will be sparse to non-existent for the next week. We're packing up this weekend and won't have internet access till the middle of next week in the new place.

Having a conversation with my father about moving the other day got me thinking about the way we think of moving. There's of course the saying that good friends are the ones who show up to help you move, and I've certainly had plenty of friends help me move in the past, so that's been borne out as far as I'm concerned.

But this move we'll be going solo. Just the four of us. Two adults and two teens are a pretty reasonable moving team - especially since we're hiring movers for the two specialty items - the pool table and the piano. I've even got my fingers crossed that the landlord calls tomorrow to say that they or the new tenants will take our washer and dryer off our hands. The new place comes with them (and they're better quality than the cheapie ones we bought while on a student budget) and if someone wants to take them off our hands, it's one less thing to move.

My dad and mom actually offered to drive 6 hours to come help us move, which of course would also likely involve sleeping on the floor and another 6 hour drive back, all probably within a couple of days. I love my mom and dad too much to take them up on such an offer. It was nice, but I wouldn't feel like a very good daughter if I agreed to something like that. I'm sure the four of us will do just fine.

But moving got me thinking about how moving and friends mix (or don't). We aren't having any friends help us this time. Mostly because I haven't asked. I already know that many of my friends are busy/on vacation this time of year. And some are just not the kind of friends who will help you move - they'll do all kinds of wonderful other things for you - but they don't even move themselves, let alone help friends move.

And sometimes I think I've got a moving-karma deficit. I feel like I've done more asking of friends to help move than I've done for friends. Not that I've ever said no to a friend who's asked for help, but I just don't think I've been asked as often as I've been the one asking. The last person I said I'd help moved changed the loading date to a day that I was out of town, so I couldn't even fulfill that promise, which I really regret. Perhaps I can be there for their next move...

So we'll be going solo. But we've booked the truck for an extended period because we knew this would be the case, so we don't have to knock ourselves out with a time limit. We're trying to be fairly zen about it, which makes it more than manageable I think. At least with a local move, you can always make a second trip if you feel the need to do so. Cross-continental moves are soooooo much harder!

One of the advantages of moving only a year after the last move is that you haven't accumulated a lot of junk. Don't get me wrong. We accumulated a lot of stuff - seems like we spent all last September and October buying crap for the house - but it hasn't hung around long enough to become junk yet, so the enormous garage sale or trip the the charity hasn't been a feature of this move.

I just find it interesting that moving brings up all kinds of thoughts and feelings that really don't surface at any other time. Maybe it's just the change that does so, or maybe there's a sense of identity associated with places that gets disrupted when you move. I'm not sure what exactly it is - I just know that moving is a really strange experience when you come right down to it.

Monday, August 20, 2007

Slow-moving hockey animals

I actually don't read the comics section of the paper that often, but yesterday's Get Fuzzy set me and my family laughing longer than usual.
(If you're having problems making out the image, follow the link instead)



Just the day before, we'd found an excellent sale price on a Flames jersey, so now I finally own one. But I'd better watch out for the sloth section when I go!

Sunday, August 19, 2007

Moving Week

So this is the week we begin moving. I say begin because we'll be stretching it out till the end of the month - which is a real luxury, especially after all our cross country moves - but it begins Friday.

Obviously posting may be even more sparse than usual... or maybe more than usual as I distract myself from boxes...

On second thought, if I'm not packing, I should be revising the paper that's due at the end of the month. So I guess if you're seeing a blog post over the next week, I'm either sailing through the revisions, or I'm logjammed against an immovable and nasty syntactical behemoth.

But while I'm off packing boxes and furiously typing, I leave you with Tenured Radical's Ten Commandments of Moving. I hope you enjoy them as much as I did!

Friday, August 17, 2007

Gone but not forgotten

Last week I had been feeling forgotten, like I was falling prey to "out of sight, out of mind" because of the vast distance between me and the academic people I hang out with.

But last night, my writing group and I met online, and it was fabulous! It took us a good week just to find a day that worked for everyone, but we did it and it was almost like being together. Almost. But it was so good to chat with the members and talk about our writing. As usual, they gave me some excellent ideas, and I'm really excited about implementing them. And I'm absolutely riveted to their narratives - I can't wait to read the next installments!

So this long distance thing does work when everyone's committed to it. It's just getting the committment that's the problem!

Thursday, August 16, 2007

I don't remember asking for the "challenge" package

Life has felt like an extra challenge the last few days. I can't even just chalk it up to moving-related stuff. It seems that every aspect of my life seems extra challenging lately.

It is 4pm already and all I can really say I've accomplished is to have taught my one hour of class today. Or at least that's all that feels like it was productive.

If I'd been sipping Mai Tai's on a beach or something the rest of the time, I wouldn't be quite so bothered, but today has been eaten up by a lot of minutiae, which is always annoying. Some of those minutiae exploded in size and the amount of time they ate up, which is doubly annoying. It's one of those days when you start looking at the clock because you can't wait for it to finally be over!

I must admit that I spent some of my time just sitting in my car. I think it was time that I needed to spend there though. This morning as I was driving between errands, I approached a green light. Since it was green, I went through. Twenty-odd years of driving has borne out the assumption that "green means go". Halfway through the intersection, I had to slam on the brakes to keep from being wiped out by a guy in a truck who blew right through a solid red light.

Guess what he was holding up to his ear?

I was shaking so badly from the shock that I had to pull over and sit in my car for a bit. Even then, I almost dropped stuff at the bank because my hands were still shaking.

My car has a really good safety rating - I just don't want to personally test how good it is.

Sunday, August 12, 2007

The good and the bad

Given my last post, I realize another personal post like this might be too much. But I still want to say it, so here goes.

Last month a good friend called me up and asked me if I'd be interested in teaching some writing courses at a local technical school. I'd been out of the classroom long enough that I said "sure!" and a little while later, she forwarded sample syllabi for the courses.

The teaching has been fabulous so far! The students are really engaged. For the most part, they're there because they want to be. Of course I do have a few students in each of the two classes I teach who think it is unimportant to come to the English class - they see little value in the class and they've told me so. I'm not making it easy on students like that because we do a lot of in class work, so they're bleeding marks rapidly.

While that may not make them see the use of being able to communicate clearly, it will force them into the classroom and participating - hopefully the incidental result is that they pick up a few things while they're there...

So far I've even enjoyed reading my students' writing. Some of it is predictable, but so much more of it than I thought I'd get is imaginative and plays with the goals of the assignments, and those ones definitely make up for the duller ones. These students aren't afraid to take risks in their writing, and while sometimes it bombs, it also pays off huge dividends for them.

The school is having some serious problems with my electronic access - I have none right now - which was mostly a minor inconvenience until Friday. On that day, I had three different administrative personnel come to ask me for the same thing, which I'm unable to deliver since I can't access any of the drives on the server. (I can access the online learning environment, which is great 'cause I can talk to my students, but I can't use any of the computers at the school to do so.)

It was a little frustrating for me to have three different people come to chew me out for not doing something that I'm unable to do. It was particularly frustrating because I'd made sure I told people about my lack of access, and they said that was fine, I could catch up on administrative paperwork later. Then all of a sudden on Friday it became urgent for me to do this, and I ended up feeling incompetent for not having solved the problem myself. Probably an overreaction, but it still felt like that.

At least this deadline put a fire under a few people's asses and it looks like they might finally get me some network access.... But I'm not holding my breath.

The biggest problem right now is that I've got two (new) class preps on top of my online work and all this moving stuff. So right now it feels like I'm constantly writing a new assignment, or otherwise prepping endlessly. I should be prepping right now instead of blogging...!

The prepping itself isn't hard - I've got lots of good material that I've developed over the years. But it does need to be adapted for the new environment, and because the pedagogical goals are different, some of it needs to be created from scratch.

One thing I'm spending lots of time writing is lab assignments. I've never taught a writing class before that had a lab component, so I have to create all those assignments from scratch.

But I'm also loving having the students sitting in front of computers for two hours a week. It gives us so many opportunities to write, and to write small assignments. It gives the students a sense of accomplishment. It allows me to play with ideas that I've had but never figured out how to work into an essay assignment. And it also gives me a chance to work with them as they write, to identify which students have which problems, so that I can tailor my writing suggestions to addressing their specific problems.

Whenever I'd have a choice about it, I would definitely choose running a writing class with a laboratory component. It's just provides so many more opportunities for the students to write.

Just thinking about writing this post made me think about how much of teaching (or any other job I suppose) consists of both the good and the bad, both inside and outside of the classroom itself.

Thursday, August 09, 2007

Isolation

When we made the decision to return home last year, I knew that writing a dissertation long distance would mean I would be more isolated from feedback and the advice/support of colleagues and advisors. I accepted this because the benefits of moving outweighed the disadvantages of it.

But I also assumed that the problems of isolation could be overcome by me if I made the effort to stay in touch. I figured that the problems would mostly arise if I didn't keep the communication lines open and keep on track.

I never really considered the possibility that my advisor or colleagues would adopt an "out of sight, out of mind" stance toward me.

But that's what's happened. It was a bit of a shock when I realized it.

Of course one of the lessons you learn in life is that there's nothing you can do to change someone else's actions. All you can do it change your response to them. My first response was a feeling of being hurt and rejected. Which of course makes it hard to contemplate continuing a relationship. While I still feel hurt by being ignored, I know the only thing I can do is to continue to make the efforts I've been making, to hold up my end of the bargain so to speak. Which I will do.

But it doesn't make the sense of isolation any easier, knowing that my communications may continue to be ignored. This is the struggle of the long distance dissertation writer I suppose. The distance makes it more evident exactly what value others place on your relationship. Perhaps it's good to know where I stand instead of assuming a support system that doesn't really exist. That way I can work to create the support system that I need.

Small things amuse small minds

I just discovered and downloaded an excellent image capture software program and am absolutely tickled at how easy screen shots for our latest work project are now going to be.

Small thing... small mind.

Tuesday, August 07, 2007

This is a public/private service?

I try to regularly read a couple of elearning sites/ejournals every week. Recently I ran across a link to this blogpost, It's not plagiarism, it's an easy essay, which simply astounded me.

The service offers to custom write essays for students. Now this is nothing new. "Betsy" at Harvard has been doing this for years. What surprised me was the justification for it. In an email interview, the Custom Writing representative has this response to a question about the organization's role in education:

No person can be equally good at everything – if he/she is, then this is the wrong path, a student talent is lost. There are people who are good at Math and IT – let them develop their skills in this field instead of torturing them with writing assignments. What is really the point of this, if students must waste hours developing skills they will never be professional in instead of concentrating on the field their future career will depend upon? I really see the role of custom writing services in education as a relief for those who have already chosen their career, who know their path, and have already somewhat succeeded in it – since services are somewhat costly and in order to buy a custom written paper, a student must have a job (the most part of our customers). Furthermore, academic writing services spare time for students to develop in the field they chose to, so, to some extent, this is a plus for their education too.

First, I really doubt students purchasing these papers are using the time they save to study. I admit it could be possible, but somehow, I doubt that time is used for learning.

Second, why is this only an argument used for writing? If as this genteman argues, one shouldn't spend time learning things that aren't directly relevant to one's line of work, then why did I suffer through all those math classes? Shouldn't I have been excused from them? Perhaps in that case there should be an organization that provides a proxy for me for math exams.

But wait a minute! you might say. You use math everyday. Whenever you go into the store and compare prices, or need to calculate the tax on something, you use math. Nobody carries around a calculator all the time, and even estimating when you'll arrive at your desination, knowing how long the trip is, takes some basic math.

And I would agree with you. I probably use math probably every day in some small way.

But I would also then argue that you use writing skills everyday as well.

Now, I admit, I know people who don't write very often, let alone every day. And yes, it's possible to get through life without learning to write coherent prose. Just as it's possible to get through life without algebra.

But there's something that the Custom Writing representative is missing here in the statement that students do now need to know how to write essays. It's the same thing I constantly harp on to my students, though I know I don't sell all of them on the idea.
"Writing" is not just about putting words on paper.

Thinking that writing an essay is about stringing together sentences and nothing more employs a very limited idea of what writing is about. Consider the OED's definition of writing: "The action of one who writes, in various senses; the penning or forming of letters or words; the using of written characters for purposes of record, transmission of ideas, etc."

The definition has three elements: the first identifies writing as an action, while the second describes the medium in which this action takes place. The third and openended element, is the one that writing teachers like myself are most interested in conveying to our students.

The transmission of ideas is the primary purpose of postsecondary writing assignments. It's also the most inclusive element in the definition, since the transmission of ideas can take many forms and can include any subject. When you think of writing as the transmission of ideas, then you hit right on the money what writing classes in postsecondary institutions are trying to teach - the ability to organize your thoughts on a particular topic into a clear transmission of those thoughts and ideas.

Being able to clearly communicate your ideas to other people is not something just required of the humanities set. Clear communication, which relies of course on critical thinking about that topic and the best method for communicating it, is required in most human endeavours that involve more than one person.

If you cannot clearly communicate your ideas to other team members, to other computer programmers or other mathematicians (to use the example from above), then you will be less successful at your job than someone who can.

This is what writing classes are designed to teach. Having students write essays is less about whether they know grammar and spelling (though problems in these areas can muddy up the meaning of what you're trying to convey), and more about whether they can think about a topic, and then arrange those thoughts in a way that makes it possible for a reader to understand what they are thinking.

This ability does not even need to be demonstrated through the putting of words on paper. This ability can be developed verbally or even visually, but the ability to arrange one's thoughts with an audience in mind in order to communicate with them is absolutely essential to most of the jobs that require any kind of postsecondary training simply because of the nature of human work and collaboration.

I can only assume it's sheer ignorance of the goals of writing programs that could lead someone to think of them as a complete waste of time and irrelevant to certain classes of students.

But then again, I'm a writing teacher, so I think these things are important. And I'll do my damnedest to show my students why it is important to them as well. Organizations like Custom Writing rob students of the opportunity to develop a skill they will need, even in the most technically oriented of jobs.

Sunday, August 05, 2007

On not knowing what's in my own mind

The long weekend has finally given me the opportunity to play catch-up in my teaching prep and in my elearning work so that I have some time to dedicate to the dissertation.

I've been fairly faithful in my New Year's resolution to think/read/write about the dissertation for at least 15 minutes a day, which has been useful in keeping my mind in dissertation mode, but you can't write a dissertation without dedicating some serious and contiguous time to working on it. So now that I have more than 15 minutes to spare every day, I've been taking advantage of it.

One of the tasks on my to do list was to map out in detail all the sections of the dissertation. Not just the chapters, which have been described in the prospectus, but the details within the chapters, section by section, or topic by topic. The plan, after mapping out this detail, is then to read what I need to write a single section, write it, then move on to the next one.

My hope is that in this way I will make the dissertation manageable, because it is big by anyone's standards, and could easily become even bigger. The idea is that unlike what I've been doing so far, which is reading a lot with less writing, I'll be reading exactly what I need, when I need to read it, and then writing the necessary section.

Funny thing is, that when I sat down to map all the sections, some of the chapters that I thought would be the easiest ones to map out, have proved the most difficult. And one chapter for which I had my doubts (and my committee expressed the same), turned out to have real justification for its existence once I sat down and filled in the details of what I wanted to talk about in that chapter.

Strange to think that what I thought was in my head, was not the same as what came out when I started to write it down.

I keep telling my writing students this - heck, I told them that just this week - and yet sometimes I forget it myself. Sometimes writing really is the only way to complete the thought process and to know what's actually in your own mind!

Wednesday, August 01, 2007

The limits of multi-tasking

Most people if you ask them will tell you they're good at multitasking. Most people will also tell you that they are better than average drivers, which of course is a statistical impossibility since at least some of those people who think they are good drivers aren't.

So, most people will tell you they think they're pretty good at multitasking.

I think for the most part I do okay at it. I have met people who cannot deal with more than one task at a time, or who become overwhelmed by multiple tasks at an earlier stage than I do. But I know I'm not superwoman.

Why does that word look funny? Shouldn't women be able to lay claim to super power as well? Perhaps Übermensch (without all that nihilism) would be a better word since it isn't gender specific, just referring to humans...

Anyway, I'm no Übermensch. But I think I've figured out one of the secrets of multitasking: you can get a lot done when it's something you've done before.

When you've done something before, you have two advantages over someone who has never done that task before: you know how long each step of it will (should) take, and your body remembers what it feels like to do that task.

Think about when you learned to ride a bike, or drive a car, or even tie your shoes. The first few times you did each of those things, it required a lot of concentration. When you learned to ride a bike, you were tempted to look at your feet on the pedals instead of where you were going because you were concentrating so hard. When you learned to drive a car, your parents probably made you turn to radio off so it wouldn't distract you. When you learned to tie your shoes, you concentrated on the task (and perhaps your tongue found its way out of the side of your mouth as you concentrated on learning how to tie your shoes... of maybe that was just me!)

When those tasks were unfamiliar, you spent a lot of mental and even physical energy learning them, but once they became familiar, you stopped thinking about them. When was the last time you thought about bunny ears, or over around and through?

But while you learn, it takes a lot of mental energy. If you're doing many activities at the same time that you've done before, you'll use much less mental energy than concentrating on trying to perform a new task.

The other advantage in multitasking things you've done before is that you know how much time everything takes. Think of the first time you tried to cook a dinner that had multiple dishes. You probably had some of the food ready far earlier than needed and were impatiently waiting for something else to cook. (Or again, maybe that was just me!) But after you've done it a few times, you know exactly when you need to start everything in order to have it on the table when you want to serve it.

(I will admit I consistently underestimate how long it will take me to cut fruit. Don't know why, but if you come over to my place for food and it's not ready, look for the fruit plate - that's what threw me off - everytime.)

I've been exhausted lately and trying to figure out why, because I've been getting enough sleep, exercise, food etc.

Then I realized - I've been doing quite a few "new" things lately, and simultaneously, and I think that's why my brain and body are rebelling. Too much overload. I'm teaching two courses at a new school, one of which is a course I've never taught before, and both require new preps to match the objectives at this particular school. We're also trying to buy a house - and we've had some hiccoughs. And we're beginning a new elearning project - one that's really far beyond any expertise that I have - I've been talking to lots of engineers and architects for the project, and they speak a language that's unfamiliar to me.

So I've reached the limits of my multi-tasking. My brain and body need a break from all these new experiences, or at the very least, it needs a lot fewer of them. I don't really see when that will happen, but until then, my ability to do multiple things at one time will be compromised.